Monday, February 13, 2012

6 1st 5 Pages February Workshop - Blair Rev 1

Title: Voice
Author: Chelsey Blair
Genre: YA Magical Realism

I couldn’t ask for help. My duffel bag sat in the luggage rack of the New York train, taunting me from two feet out of my reach. Other passengers pushed by me, their eyes meeting mine for a split second each. If I could only force the words excuse me out of my mouth. If my voice box would cooperate for half a second I could get one of them to lift it down for me.

No chance of that.

I hadn’t spoken to a non-family memeber in eight years.

“Can I give you a hand, young lady?” the conductor asked, with a wink.

I let him help me lower things into the aisle. The duffel bag that held my art supplies clattered on the way down.

“There you go. Time to start your New York adventure.”

His expectant gaze made my stomach clench. Hadn’t he figured it out earlier? He’d come by to take our tickets and asked where we’d be going. I’d sat there with my lips glued shut. My stepsister, Jessica, had taken her time intervening. She’d made a game of seeing how long I could last before total panic overtook me. Now she wasn’t around to take up the slack, I would have to watch his gaze turn puzzled, then disappointed, then resigned. He’d walk away thinking he’d encountered the rudest girl ever and—

“Thank you,” a voice said.

I scanned the aisle. Everyone else had left the train. The conductor didn’t join in my search for a mysterious interloper. He nodded, and pushed past me to the door of the train.
So, unless somebody had said the words seconds before dematerializing, the person who’d spoken had been me.

I’d spoken.

To a stranger.

I inhaled, waiting for my breath to catch. Waiting for the panic attack that would invariably follow. My anxiety seemed to have been somehow delayed. If I hurried, maybe I could make it off the train before it caught up.

I slung my bag over my shoulder, but couldn’t go any further. My focus zeroed in on my luggage tag. K. Anderson, it said in Dad’s neat script. He liked things tidy and predictable. So did I. But we could never have predicted what had just happened.

I had thanked the conductor.

If an impatient voice hadn’t broken into my thoughts, I might have stayed there, a breathing version of Rodin’s “The Thinker”, forever attempting to figure out what this meant.

“If you’re chickening out, you’ll still have to get on a different train.”

I met Jessica’s gaze, hoping she’d read what had happened on my face. She only scowled. She’d stopped trying to figure me out.

We banged our bags through Penn Station. Jessica’s long legs propelled her way ahead of me. I struggled to keep up, my mind still reeling.

I had spoken to the conductor.

Without severe psychological trauma.

What had changed in the half-hour since he took our tickets? Jessica spent the ride flipping through a Cosmo magazine. I’d had my laptop out, browsing the Selective Mutism messageboards I read sometimes. Someone had replied to a message I’d posted a year ago, about how desperate I’d been to speak to Jessica again.

If you could speak to her, what would you say?

I’m sorry. I’m sorry. I’m sorry, I’d replied. The second I’d hit send, the computer had frozen. Then the screen pixelated, and went dark.

I’d still been jabbing the restart button when the train stopped.

Had that done something?

“Kyra, move your ass!” Jessica shouted. I’d frozen again, in the center of the corridor. I hurried to take my place in the cab line. It moved faster than I thought such a large group of people could. Fine, I based my expectations on the sluggish pace of the Grott’s Crossing cafeteria line, but I couldn’t believe how little time passed before we’d taken our seats in the back of a cab with a driver asking, “Where to?”

Jessica rummaged through her purse. I listened to the sound of crumpling paper for a beat and then reached into my messenger bag. Dad had put together a folder of all the paperwork we’d been sent. I glanced at the cards he’d made for these occasions. They had the address and cross streets all typed out. I took one out to hand to the driver. He twisted in his seat, impatience oozing from every drop of sweat the summer afternoon brought to his face.

I kept my eyes on the serif font on the card. “122 East 12th. It’s 12th between Third and Fourth Avenues.”

I ran my tongue along the edges of my teeth, letting them bite into it a little. It hurt. That should mean I wasn’t dreaming. I couldn’t believe it. Any minute now the conductor would shake me awake. I’d look into his eyes and my mouth would refuse to open. He’d—

A clatter from beside me brought me back to myself, and I turned away from the card in time to see twenty of Jessica’s makeup bottles tumble out of her purse.

“What the hell?” she demanded. “Did you just—?”

My brain filled in the talk, but the cab driver obviously thought I’d given him the wrong address. “Your friend lie to me?”

She slowly shook her head and he pulled into traffic. I’d bent over to pick up her makeup, but I could feel her bug-eyed stare on me. I wanted her to ask what’d happened, or maybe even to be excited about this development. “She’s my stepsister. Not my friend,” she informed the driver.

No shocked demands. No have you been faking all this time? No a cabdriver, but not me? No sign she cared at all.

I handed over her restocked purse and turned to the window. The nearest street sign said we’d turned onto Fourth Avenue. The no-smoking decal on the window mocked my jangling nerves.

“Those buildings are so oppressive,” Jessica commented. “They block out the sky. It feels so unnatural.”

Your tone is unnatural, I thought, sticking my nail underneath one of the rolled edges of the decal to help it along in the unsticking process. She didn’t exude half the passion I’d have expressed if I could. I stopped picking at the adhesive on the window. Could I now?

I licked my lips, focusing on the window, trying to pretend the driver wasn’t there. I used to be able to talk to Jessica alone, the same way I could talk to Dad, but for the past year I’d been gripped with anxiety attacks even around her. I clenched my fist, awaiting the familiar signs of terror, and ventured, “There’s a park over there. The natural tones of the flowers sort of balance out the manufactured grays next to them, don’t you think?”

At first, I thought I hadn’t been able to say the words. They echoed in my head the way they tended to because I couldn’t let them out.

“They are pretty flowers,” the cab driver offered. I smiled at the rearview mirror. He couldn’t know what he’d just validated.

Once-upon-a-time Jessica would never have ignored something I said.

“Oh look, there’s a Gap!” she exclaimed a second later. “Maybe you could try picking out your own clothes while we’re here, instead of relying on your daddy.”

I could remind her who stopped going to the store with me, I thought, but I didn’t bother. What would it change?


  1. What an interesting concept! And it's nice to have such a unique problem for the MC. I think you could have a really great story here.

    The issue I have with these first pages is that instead of setting up a problem, it seems to actually SOLVE the MC's problem, giving no real hint about where the story might go from there. If you showed her unable to speak, then I'd assume the story would be about her journey to finally speak. The tension would rise with situations where she wouldn't be able to get the words out, some panic attacks, and we'd be rooting for her to get the words out. But if she is already making a breakthrough now, we can assume she will continue to do so, thus deflating the main story tension.

    I suggest considering that in a general story structure, you'll introduce a problem at the beginning of the story that gets worse until the climax where you finally get the solution. So if the problem is already getting better in the first five pages, it's as if we've just read the climax rather than the beginning of the story.

    Best of luck!

  2. Hi Chelsea,

    I think I'm starting to see where you are going with the apology. It's fascinating, but I didn't truly feel that you captured that in quite the right way yet. Her mind going straight there was more cludgy than realistic. I also still have a problem with her not even realizing that her mouth is moving--but maybe that's just me. I LOVE the new beginning. Love it. It grounds us, jumps us right into the story, which in this version seems clearly to be about what the apology and the situation surrounding it. At least, I hope that's what it's about?

    If so, I wonder if you could show us the two pieces that you backtracked to in this version in real time? Perhaps if you started with the new intro in the context of the conductor asking for the ticket and Jessica being a witch about putting her on the spot and combined that with trying to hit the send button on the apology conversation in some way?

    Eager to see where you're going and how you will handle this! :D



  3. I'm definitely intrigued. This could just be me, but I was assuming that her arriving in NY had magically changed her, and that the book would be about her finding out why it had done so, and then solving other problems that came up (don't know why I was thinking this, but I assumed they'd be paranormal, powers-type problems).

    I'd like to know soon-ish exactly WHY she's in NY with only her stepsister when there's obviously animosity between them. I wouldn't mind knowing in the first few paragraphs, actually--before the inciting incident. (I figured her speaking to a stranger for the first time in years to be the inciting incident.) Just a hint would be fine, a sentence or two at most. But I'd like a teeny, tiny bit more backstory before everything gets turned on its head.

    Great writing! LOVED the "sticking my nail underneath one of the rolled edges of the decal to help it along in the unsticking process."

  4. Hi Chelsey!

    I really like what you've done with this revision! I particularly like the suggestion of the magical realism to come with the way you've described the message board -- and it's great to know the context for those messages! That makes a world of difference.
    I like Martina's suggestion of starting earlier so we can experience the message board in real time (with more focus on it than you originally had in your first version) because I would see that as the real inciting incident. But what's tricky with magical realism is that it's usually not going to be obvious what's going on at first. If you just back up and tell the story from the time of the messageboard, I have a hard time imagining how you could have us sense the importance of that messageboard apology.
    You know, I think you condensed things so the messageboard incident is followed immediately by some talking, that could work. What if you have her living the message board stuff in real-time, and while the train stops and Jessica gets off, she still sitting there hitting restart (because she's so frustrated about not being able to communicate and then even her computer won't let her), and then the conductor comes by with some question or "time to get off the train" type comment?

    Good luck!!

  5. Hi! Love it!!! Now I see what you're doing with the message board. So here's my suggestion: Start with her on the train on the message board. Let her glance at Jessica and consider what she'd say. Let her fill in the info about not speaking (for those that don't get selective mutism." Have the train jolt to a stop and the pixalation occur. THEN continue on from there. I think that would work out perfectly. I really do like it.

  6. Chelsey,

    This is so much smoother. I'm able to really take it all in and swoon. I would also consider leading with the message board. It worked recalling it later, but would be less confusing early on. That said, if this was on a shelf I would pick it up and take it home. Great job revising.

    A few tiny things could be adjusted. The line after Jessica realizes Kyra spoke to the cab driver: "My brain filled in the talk". Revise this line. Also, there was one misspelling of the word "member" in the third paragraph (so minor).


Tell us what you think. We'd love to hear from you! :)